
Strategy Executive Chairman Michael Saylor has pushed back against claims that the company’s recent $181 million share sale diluted existing shareholders, arguing that critics misunderstand how value should be measured.
In a response posted on X, Saylor addressed concerns raised by Bitcoin analyst Matthew R. Kratter, who pointed to a decline in Strategy’s BTC Yield metric between June 1 and June 8 as evidence of dilution. Saylor countered that BTC Yield measures the increase in Bitcoin per share, not overall shareholder accretion, and highlighted that the transaction added both Bitcoin and cash to the company’s balance sheet.
Data from Strategy shows the company acquired 1,550 BTC for approximately $101.3 million during the week ending June 7, at an average price of $65,332 per Bitcoin. The company also boosted its dollar reserves by $100 million, bringing total cash reserves to roughly $1 billion. Saylor emphasized that when both assets are considered, the transaction was accretive for MSTR shareholders.
According to Strategy’s latest disclosures, the company now holds 845,256 BTC valued at approximately $51.9 billion at current market prices. The year-to-date BTC Yield stands at 12.8%, with a BTC Gain of 86,328 BTC. The share sale involved the issuance of over 1.4 million MSTR shares, and executives sold about $15 million worth of stock for tax purposes.
Despite Saylor’s defense, some analysts remain cautious. A Fortune analysis highlighted that Strategy’s combined debt and preferred stock obligations have surged from around $6.9 billion in early 2025 to approximately $21.8 billion, driven largely by preferred stock issuances. Fortune also noted that Strategy’s stock trades at a roughly 31% premium above its net asset value, a premium that could shrink if Bitcoin prices fall or investor concerns about the company’s capital structure intensify.
In a scenario where Bitcoin drops to $50,000, Fortune estimated that Strategy’s net asset value could decline to about $23 billion while liabilities remain steady. JPMorgan previously described the company’s first Bitcoin sale in over four years—a small disposal of 32 BTC for $2.5 million in late May—as largely symbolic, aimed at demonstrating flexibility to preferred shareholders. The bank warned that future dividend commitments could become challenging if cash reserves dwindle.
Saylor rejected the dilution narrative, stating that the combination of Bitcoin acquisition and cash reserve growth made the move beneficial for shareholders. The debate underscores ongoing scrutiny of Strategy’s capital management strategy as the company continues to expand its Bitcoin holdings through debt and equity offerings.








