On Thursday, Nigeria’s Supreme Court delivered a significant judgment in the ongoing leadership dispute within the opposition African Democratic Congress (ADC). In a unanimous decision by a five-member panel led by Justice Mohammed Lawal Garba, the court nullified a prior Court of Appeal directive that had ordered parties to maintain the status quo. The apex court ruled that the appellate court overstepped its jurisdiction after dismissing the appeal before it.
However, the Supreme Court did not definitively name the legitimate leader of the ADC. Instead, it instructed all parties to return to the trial court for the case to continue. This has left room for differing interpretations among party stakeholders.
Mixed Reactions from Party Figures
Mansur Umar Kurugu, spokesperson II of the Kwankwasiyya Movement, expressed optimism about the ruling, stating it reaffirms faith in Nigeria’s judiciary. He remarked, “This ruling boosts our confidence in the judicial system. It shows that some institutions still uphold their integrity and values.” Kurugu also criticized the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), alleging bias against opposition parties.
In contrast, Dumebi Kachikwu argued that no faction can claim victory from the verdict. He stated, “The Supreme Court displayed wisdom by refusing to be used as a tool for destabilization by the David Mark-led group. It directed both sides back to the trial court, leaving the leadership question unresolved.”
Implications for Coalition Talks and 2027 Elections
Adnan Mukhtar, a former Kano State House of Assembly aspirant and ADC member, viewed the ruling as a positive development for the party and the nation. He said, “The ADC is the only opposition party serious about challenging President Bola Ahmed Tinubu. This judgment is a wake-up call for the party to field competent candidates in the 2027 general elections.” Mukhtar added that the decision clears the way for party activities like primaries and nomination form sales.
Nevertheless, analysts caution that coalition partners may remain hesitant to fully engage with the ADC until the leadership issue is finally settled in court. The party still faces a trial at the Federal High Court.
Claims and Counterclaims
Nafi’u Bala, another figure in the fray, dismissed the notion that the ruling is a victory for any faction. He insisted, “How does dismissing a case mean victory? I am the authentic ADC leader in Nigeria. I will continue to fight until we reclaim our party from those who ruined theirs.” He labeled the David Mark faction as outsiders seeking to hijack the party.
Several prominent leaders, including Senator Aminu Waziri Tambuwal and Atiku Abubakar, have responded with cautious optimism, reminding members that while the ruling is encouraging, the legal battle is far from over.